Phase 1 Verification Report: Scaffold and Frozen Contracts
Phase Goal: Repo is a strict ESM TypeScript package with working quality scripts; every shared contract and integration gate exists before any module code. Verified: 2026-10-21 (gates re-run by verifier on commit e949ad3) Status: passed Score: 4/4 success criteria verified; FOUND-01..03, QUAL-01 satisfied.
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
| # | Truth (from ROADMAP Success Criteria) | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Developer can run typecheck, lint, test, build on the ESM strict-mode package, each completing with no suppressed errors | ✓ VERIFIED | npm run typecheck exit 0; npm run lint exit 0 ("No issues found"); npm test exit 0 (187 tests: 186 pass, 0 fail, 1 skipped Podman gate); npm run test:integration exit 0 (12 tests: 11 pass, 0 fail, 1 skipped); npm run build exit 0. package.json has "type": "module"; tsconfig.json has strict: true, module/moduleResolution: NodeNext. Grep for `@ts- |
| 2 | State table, typed error catalogue, tool schema, session-record schema, policy schema exist at specified paths; contract tests show each schema rejecting invalid input | ✓ VERIFIED | src/core/states.ts (6 states, 13-edge frozen table), src/core/errors.ts (21-code frozen catalogue), src/contract/tools.schema.json, src/contract/session-record.schema.json, src/core/policy.schema.json, plus wrapper src/contract/validate.ts (returns SCHEMA_INVALID, never throws; non-cloneable input → typed failure). Rejection tests, all passing: test/core/states.test.ts "the matrix covers 36 ordered pairs: 13 allowed and 23 rejected"; test/core/policy.schema.test.ts "any other mode string is rejected", "startupBudgetMs of zero is rejected"; test/contract/tools.schema.test.ts "exec argv form with a script key is rejected" (+28 more); test/contract/session-record.schema.test.ts "a record missing sessionId is rejected"; test/contract/validate.test.ts "a function input returns SCHEMA_INVALID instead of throwing". |
| 3 | Integration notes exist under docs/integration/ for all 8 sources, each citing official URL and read date; no integration module without its note | ✓ VERIFIED | All 8 present: agentos.md, podman.md, openshell.md, anda.md, omp.md, mcp.md, acp.md, hosts.md. Each carries official URLs (e.g. acp.md → agentclientprotocol.com protocol pages; anda.md → github.com/ldclabs/anda + raw manifests; agentos.md → rivet.dev URLs) and Read date: 2026-10-21. src/ contains only core/ + contract/ — zero integration modules exist, so none is unwarranted. |
| 4 | Every async boundary has a timeout; every error carries machine-readable code + human-readable reason; no silent catch blocks | ✓ VERIFIED | Sole async boundary is the Podman probe: PROBE_TIMEOUT_MS = 5_000 passed as execFile timeout (test/integration/podman-gate.test.ts:11,17). Every error is a RealmError/SchemaInvalidError with catalogue code + reason + retryable (all 21 entries carry a reason string). Only catch in src/ is validate.ts:270, which returns a typed SCHEMA_INVALID error (not empty; no-empty lint passes). |
Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|
| FOUND-01 | package.json scripts + tsconfig.json strict ESM; gates above, all exit 0 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| FOUND-02 | src/core/states.ts, src/core/errors.ts, src/contract/tools.schema.json, src/contract/session-record.schema.json, src/core/policy.schema.json, src/contract/validate.ts; rejection tests listed in Truth 2 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| FOUND-03 | docs/integration/*.md (8 files) with URLs + read dates; src/ has no integration modules | ✓ SATISFIED |
| QUAL-01 | 5 s probe timeout; typed errors only; no silent catches (Truth 4) | ✓ SATISFIED |
Anti-Patterns
None. No TODO/FIXME/XXX, no return null/[]/{} stubs, no hardcoded empty data flows, no console.log-only handlers in src/.
Behavioral Spot-Checks
Covered by the gate runs above (real tsc, eslint, node --test executions, not grep-only). The Podman skip in both suites names the detected version and code: "Podman 4.9.3 detected; OpenShell requires Podman 5.x; PODMAN_UNSUPPORTED_VERSION".
Human Verification Required
None. No UI, flow, or external-service behavior is in scope for this phase.
Gaps Summary
No gaps. Prior review findings M-1 (exec argv hole) and the validate() DataCloneError are closed in the committed code with negative tests; prior major M-2 (ajv placement) is resolved — ajv 8.20.0 is now under dependencies in the committed package.json.
Verified: 2026-10-21Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)